Steve Harms

Friday, August 23, 2013

Collections: knowing when it is time to take the next step in the collection process...


If you have good collection policies, your policies include timeframes in which to take certain actions, such as the following:

                           *  Following up with demand letters requiring payment when an account balance becomes delinquent.

                           *  Following up with collection phone calls when demand letters don’t produce payment.

                           *  Immediately following up with the debtor when the debtor doesn’t keep promises to make payment.

When you’ve taken the actions defined by your collection policy (see my book, Credit and Collections Kit for Dummies for specific credit policies you can implement) and your debtor still hasn’t paid, you should shift into collections mode. Delay in initiating collection action, including bringing in collections professionals as appropriate, can be the death knell for collecting on the account. If your debtor still has (or may have) some ability to pay but continues to stall payment, you need to move quickly.
Remember, accounts that aren't collected within 12 months after the due date are generally only 10% collectable!

After you decide to start the collections process, do you collect the delinquent account yourself, or do you bring in a professional? You should consider placing an account with a professional when

                           *  Lines of communication between you and the debtor have completely broken down.

                           *  You can’t reach your debtor by phone, and you think your debtor may have skipped town.

                           *  You sense that your debtor has financial difficulties and has several other unpaid creditors who will be going after what’s left of your debtor’s money.

                           *  You don’t trust the debtor’s words or intentions because of the passage of time since the last payment and the number of promises the debtor has broken.

                           *  Your debtor’s delinquency threatens your own credit by putting you in danger of violating standards set by your auditors, banks, factors, or receivable insurance contracts.

                           *  Your instinct tells you it’s time to bring in a professional.

Strive for a solid relationship with your collection agency or attorney in which the agency or lawyer is an extension of your credit department. Without a good relationship, you may feel awkward referring a case to an outside collector, but relying on team members for assistance seems only natural.

Thursday, August 15, 2013

Collections alert: debt buyers may not be able to add interest to purchased accounts


The following is a summary of a new Michigan case on the subject of debt buyers adding interest to their accounts...it is a warning, of sorts:
 
Asset Acceptance purchases pools of charged-off credit cards.  In its purchasing agreements, there is clause where the original debtor waived its right to charge interest after the date of charge off.  After Asset purchased the accounts, they brought suit for the charged-off amount, plus interest from the date of charge off to the date of filing the complaint in state court.

 This was held to be a violation of the FDCPA.  “Because [the original creditors] waived interest, Asset could not retroactively impose interest for the period in which it did not own the accounts.” “Further, Asset purchased the debts subject to the waiver, thereby precluding Asset from imposing interest or revoking the original creditor’s waiver”.  Thus, Asset violated Sec. 1692e(2)(A) and 1692f(1). 

 Also worth noting, it appears that the violation occurs upon the filing of the state court action, and the statute of limitations on the violation is 1 year from that date.

 BOTTOM LINE…. EITHER REVIEW THE DEBT-PURCHASER’S PURCAHSER’S AGREEMENT TO SEE IF WE CAN COLLECT INTEREST POST-CHARGE-OFF, OR (BETTER YET), DON’T CLAIM INTEREST FROM THE DATE OF CHARGE-OFF!!!

Tuesday, June 25, 2013

Advantages of being a SECURED CREDITOR when it comes to bill collecting

There are significant advantages to being a secured creditor versus being unsecured. This is particularly true if there are several creditors competing against the same pool of assets when a debtor defaults in payments. This is extremely significant should the debtor file for bankruptcy.

Let’s take an example. A debtor is struggling and seeks money from several sources. Bank A provides a loan on an unsecured basis. Bank B provides a loan containing a lien on assets which is not perfected. Bank C loans money, taking a perfected security interest in collateral through either possession or properly filed financing statement and security agreement.

The debtor runs into financial problems and starts defaulting on loans. Trade creditors are typically unsecured. Trade creditors file suits quickly because they know they must move swiftly. This typically has a domino effect. In other words, once trade creditors start filing their collection lawsuits, secured creditors move in in order to protect their collateral.

In the circumstance described above, bank A provided a loan on an unsecured basis so it is basically in the same situation as the trade creditors. Should the debtor’s business fail completely, trade creditors usually receive less than $.10 on the dollar and bank A will find itself in that position, typically. Therefore, being an unsecured creditor is very dangerous. The only reason trade creditors are unsecured is because of competition. If a trade creditor were to try and seek a security interest in its collateral, the debtor would simply go down the street and purchase goods from another vender, particularly if those goods were commodities, which are easy to find.

Bank B loaned money and a security agreement was attached but was not perfected. Therefore, a security agreement is valid as between the bank and the debtor, but not valid as protection against third parties. Bank three did perfect. Therefore, if bank A, bank B and bank C start to move in on the collateral at the same time, bank C wins. A perfected creditor is going to have superior collateral rights to a creditor who has only attached a security interest, which is the situation with bank B. Bank A, as indicated above, is just another unsecured creditor with no rights against assets of the debtor absent a legal judgment.

In a worst case scenario, the debtor files for bankruptcy. Bank A and Bank B are both out of luck. They are being treated as unsecured creditors and unsecured creditors typically get less than $.10 on the dollar in bankruptcy liquidations.Bank C, by way of contrast, gets to foreclose on its collateral in most circumstances and at least will recover some money, depending on the value of the collateral it secured. If the collateral is worth the full amount of the loan, bank three will be made whole. Banks A and B will, as stated, be walking away with less than $.10 on the dollar.

In order to appreciate the difference between the secured positions of Bank B and Bank C, the following discussion is offered. Bank B attached, but did not perfect its interest as a secured creditor, whereas Bank C attached and perfected. Attaching and perfecting are separate concepts, and both are necessary to attain the highest status of becoming a truly secured creditor.

To attach, the parties simply prepare and sign a security agreement, which is a document describing the collateral and pledging the collateral as security to the debt. It should be noted while we normally consider the security agreement to be written, and electronic version is perfectly acceptable in most jurisdictions.

Perfection, under the Uniform Commercial Code occurs in commercial transactions where the lien is filed with the appropriate authorities; typically the Secretary of State in the state where the debtor transacts business and sometimes a copy is filed within the local county (a political sub-division of the state) where the property is located. Simply put, the filing is the action which creates perfection of the lien.

The filing process is very inexpensive and there are forms readily available. These forms are typically referred to as “UCC 1” forms or “Financing Statements”. Lenders who choose to do business with a particular debtor will search the public records to find evidence of other secured creditors. A search through the records of the Secretary of State will turn up all filed financing statements. A creditor can then be aware of persons or businesses which have taken a lien on collateral. These same public record searches also show any tax liens filed against a debtor. A creditor can then be guided accordingly in making a decision as to whether to lend money or not. For example, if you are loaning money, you need to know whether your debtor has other secured creditors or tax liens having liens on the same property you are about to take as collateral!

It is extremely valuable to be a perfected secured creditor! This is particularly true if you are a lender. Lenders deal exclusively in money. They don’t provide a product; they simply are in business to loan money and recover it back plus interest in order to make a profit. Therefore, it is extremely important for lenders to loan money on a secured basis.

Manufacturers, to the contrary, take more risk in terms of providing goods to their customers on open account terms, which means on an unsecured basis. Presumably, the manufacturer has a sufficient profit that it can absorb certain losses each year for maybe 2% or 3% of its customers failing to pay/filing for bankruptcy. In a situation where a manufacturer is operating on a very tight profit margin or, where a manufacturer provides “big ticket items”, very expensive milling machines or robots, a manufacturer in this category would be foolish to continue to do business with debtors who were “marginal” without taking a security interest in the products that it sells.

Whether a lender or a manufacturer, or any other position in the “chain” of commerce, it pays to be a perfected secured creditor!


Author:


Steven A. Harms


Muller, Muller, Richmond, Harms & Myers


33233 Woodward Avenue


Birmingham, MI 48009


248-645-2440


Fax: 248-645-5478


steve@mullerfirm.com

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Collections: Getting Slow Payers Back on Track!

Stopping Slow Payers in Their Tracks


Short of going over to your customer and handing them their check book so they can write you a check for payment on outstanding invoices, the most effective action you can take to keep customer payments coming in smoothly is to closely monitor progress and communicate with the customer as often as necessary to keep the check or checks coming in promptly. You might even look at this as a training process. You are literally training your customers to respect your selling terms.

At the first sign of slowness, which will show up on your aging sheet, communicate promptly in writing. At this stage, the letter is just a gentle reminder. It is important to keep good customer relations. After all, the customer may have just simply forgotten to make the payment.

The next communication may be just as polite but should be done by phone. It seems there are quite a few ways to communicate with customers these days but the two most effective ways to communicate are still two of the oldest: face to face contact and the telephone. Face to face contact is probably not practical or even possible with most of your customers (years ago in house bill collectors were common place. A lot of shoe leather was spent knocking on doors and collecting accounts). The telephone is a close second, however. 

Avoiding Bad Habits and Broken Promises

Using a letter plus a very polite telephone call acts to keep an otherwise good paying customer in line. It also acts as a quick signal to you if a customer does not keep a commitment. For example, if you contact a customer on Tuesday and that customer indicates a check is in the mail to you that day, you may expect to have that check in your possession a few days later. If it doesn’t arrive, a follow up communication is necessary to see if some chance the check is lost in the mail but the odds are greater that the customer has simply broken his promise to you.

Watching for Fires and Putting Them Out Quickly

When it comes to collecting on invoices from customers, it is much better to be pro active than reactive. Simply put, you need to stay ahead of the game by spotting problem areas very promptly and following up with quick action. The following is a discussion of typical areas in customer relations in connection with the prompt payment of invoices.

Changes In Ownership of A client Business

A change in ownership of the customer can change bill paying habits dramatically. You may have had a great relationship with a customer for years which may have resulted in being lax on updating credit information such as information contained on the credit application, financial statements and  other documentation. Upon making a call, you may discover that there are different voices on the phone and it can be revealed that new ownership took over. The name of the company remained the same so as to show some continuity of business. People like to deal with businesses that have been around for a while with little change.

Perhaps the most dramatic event which can occur on a change of ownership was refusal of the new owners to pay debts incurred by the prior owners. For example, if the change of ownership occurred in June last year, even though the name of the company remained the same, no changes were reported to you, an investigation may have to be initiated as to which invoices were actually sold to the prior owners, which invoices were sold to the current owners, and are the current owners liable for the debts of the prior owners. 

Changes in ownership can significantly affect bill paying habits. Therefore, this is a key reason to periodically have your client submit a new credit application as the application itself defines the name of the business entity and who the owners are. Don’t count on your customer to be forth right in providing that information.

Changes of Address or Phone Number

Observing a change of address or phone number is significant. It may reflect new ownership. It may be a result of a conflict with the landlord (an eviction perhaps).

Two trends have become increasingly popular in terms of address and phone number. With regard to addresses, it is increasingly common for small and medium sized businesses to show a post office box as the address or, more disturbing, the address of a mail drop service (such as a UPS store) as the physical address of the company. It is much easier for a customer to become elusive if a physical address is not disclosed to you. If a customer uses a post office box or a mail drop address, your credit application or some other form should insist that a physical address also be disclosed. 

A customer having the same phone number for a long period of time use to signify stability because phone numbers were tied in with addresses. Now, a phone number can receive a call and through modern technology that call can be forwarded anywhere in the world. Thus, a customer having the same phone number for a long period of time no longer signifies stability. You must keep tabs on the customer as to the physical address where the customer is located per the discussion above.


Enforcing Good Pay to Improve Your Cash Flow

Both a seller and a buyer are more comfortable with their relationship when goods and services are flowing smoothly and payments for those goods and services are being made promptly. You will find your customers do not object to close monitoring and eager follow up for prompt payment of invoices. Indeed, those customers who do find your close monitoring to be offensive, are customers you probably are going to have some trouble with down the road any way.

Wednesday, April 17, 2013

Debt collection starts with a credit application!

Debt collection really begins when you first sign on your client or customer!  At the beginning of the relationship, you aren't anticipating collection problems, of course, but you do know that a certain percentage of customers go bad and turn into collection problems.

So, why not protect yourself right from the beginning, starting with a credit application (you may not call it that, but you should have a form that new clients/patients/customers fill out).

What should it contain, well consider these items:

Consider accumulating the information in some way so that you have the following data on each of your clients:


1. The correct and full legal name of the applicant, the physical address (not merely a post office box), and the position of the individual who is applying (treasurer, president, etc.). To make sure that the customer clearly specifies the type of business entity, provide check-off boxes for proprietorship is also a good idea.

2. Any trade names the company operates under. For example, if the Brake Shop is a division of Win Management Corporation, the application should require that both names be listed along with the relationship between the two.

3. Names, addresses, and telephone numbers of any authorized purchasers at any branches.

4. Names, addresses, telephone numbers, and social security numbers of partners and officers.

5. Name, address, and telephone number of the bank where the company maintains its accounts.

6. Names, addresses, and telephone numbers of several trade references.

7. Type of product(s) sold.

8. Year the business was formed.

9. A statement similar to the following: “A signature on this document provides permission to pull a credit bureau report on any individual who may be liable under this agreement (such as a personal guarantor, proprietor, general partner, or similar person).”

10. Financial statements.

11. Amount of credit requested.

12. Anticipated monthly purchases.

13. A statement that the customer agrees to pay interest at a specific percentage rate, or the maximum legal rate of interest from the date of the last invoice. The interest charges are to be construed as a time-price differential and therefore not considered interest.

14. A personal guaranty, which should be obtained on all credit applications. Obviously, the signing of a personal guaranty is optional and requires a separate signature from the signature on the credit application itself. The language of the personal guaranty should be somewhat similar to the following:

Should the account become delinquent, the undersigned personally guarantees payment of the account balance to Creditor Company plus the interest and other charges referred to in this application, including reasonable attorney fees. This is a guaranty of payment. The guaranty is personal in nature and the undersigned acknowledges personal liability and consents to having a credit bureau report ordered by the creditor.

Monday, April 1, 2013

Service of Summons and Complaint to collect money

A collection law suit (or any suit for that matter) is started by filing a Complaint, which lets the debtor (defendant) know--in a matter of numbered paragraphs--what you are suing for.  That is, it explains the contract or account, and then the balance currently owed plus any interest/costs. 

The suit also includes a cover sheet referred to as a Summons, which is form language required by the court explaining to the debtor the case number, how many days to answer the suit, the fact that this is a suit, and some other details.

BOTH the Summons and the Complaint must be served on the debtor/defendant, within the time allowed before it expires (the Summons may have the expiration date right on it).

If the defendant is an individual, as opposed to a business, personal service is required.  This generally means the debtor (at least in Michigan, and the practice does vary a bit from state to state, country to country) is handed the document.  However, in Michigan at least, this does not require a physical touching of the Summons and Complaint.  It does require three things:  Inform the debtor of the action; offer them to the debtor; and leave them in the debtor's physical control.

So, what does the process server do if the debtor takes off running into his house and slams the door (happens often, or some variation of this)?  Well, the process server shouts that he is delivering a suit, he offers to hand the papers (remember...BOTH the Summons and the Complaint) to the debtor, then he leaves them right outside the door, or in the door handle,  if the debtor refuses to open the door he just ran into.  That is sufficient.  In one case, the papers made it half way into the door as it was being slammed shut, the debtor grabbed them out of the door and threw them back at the process server.  Still good service according to the Michigan Court of Appeals.  Barclay v Crown Building is one good example.

Michigan also allows service on an individual by certified mail if the delivery is restricted to a specifically identified person, and if that person signs for it and the receipt is produced.

There are also a number of ways to obtain substituted service, but that requires a petition or motion be filed with the court, and court permission to so serve the papers...effective if direct service just isn't going to happen.  Frequently the plaintiff who started the suit will also petition the court for an extended Summons if the process server runs out of time, usually requiring an affidavit from the process server and other address verification such as a postal trace from the Post Office.

What may seem easy, sometimes isn't.  Completing good service of a law suit is a prime example of that!

Wednesday, March 6, 2013

FDCPA update: Mortgage foreclosure work is debt collection

The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit ruled in Glazer v Chase Home Finance (decided January 2013) that mortgage foreclosure work is debt collection under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act.  Lawyers who meet the definition of being "debt collectors" must therefore comply with the FDCPA when engaged in mortgage foreclosure as per the facts in the Glazer case. 

This may come as a shock to some as this type of work is frequently not considered to be debt collection.  The logic the Sixth Circuit used was that the foreclosure is basically a means to an end, and the end is to collect the amount owed on the note that accompanied the mortgage.  Assuming the loan from the note secured by the property foreclosed upon was used for personal, family or household use, the logic follows that the proceeds of the foreclosure action are being used to pay a consumer debt which is the heart and sole of the FDCPA...this case, of course from the context, involved a consumer debt or, as the court called it: a home loan to a consumer.

Michigan Law App for your i-phone

http://www.michigan.gov/documents/cis_ofis_ceilings_24956_7.pdf

A few comments on Michigan Collection practices

Just a few quick comments on Michigan collections (I usually try to make comments in a generic fashion, applicable to most of our states) as follows:

1. MCL 600.2559 has been amended.  This has to do with court officer fees for service of process and related service charges.  For example, personal service of a suit is now $23.00 plus mileage; and service of a garnishment is $20.00 plus mileage.  Writs to seize assets: 7% of the first $8000 and 3% of amounts over that are owed to the officer; plus posting fees and other expenses (see .2559 (1).  The amended section calls for further fee increases each year in 2014 and 2015 as well.  These fee charges are all reasonable and necessary, but they are something attorneys working in enforcement of judgments should be aware of.

2. Cool apps are available.  Check out MICHIGAN COURTS in the App Store for I-phones, I-pads and I Pod touch for powerful tools including State and Federal court rules, access to PACER and the like.   Try:
http://www.michigan.gov/documents/cis_ofis_ceilings_24956_7.pdf

Friday, March 1, 2013

FDCPA defendant may recover costs against an unsuccessful plaintiff

Good news for collectors who are sued unsuccessfully by a plaintiff for violating the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA): the United States Supreme Court just ruled that the defendant in the case may recover costs against the unsuccessful plaintiff. 

The plaintiff in the case before the Supreme Court argued that costs could only be assessed against a plaintiff if the action was brought in "bad faith" as per Section 1692 k (a)(3) of the FDCPA.

The Supreme Court said the bad faith requirement does NOT prevent a court from awarding costs against a plaintiff who brings a FDCPA claim, even if in good faith, if the suit is unsuccessful. A portion of the rather long opinion is attached here:



Petitioner Marx filed suit, alleging that General Revenue Corporation (GRC) violated the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) by harassing and falsely threatening her in order to collect on a debt.The District Court ruled against Marx and awarded GRC costs pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure (FRCP) 54(d)(1), which gives district courts discretion to award costs to prevailing defendants“[u]nless a federal statute . . . provides otherwise.” Marx sought to vacate the award, arguing that the court’s discretion under Rule54(d)(1) was displaced by 15 U. S. C. §1692k(a)(3), which provides, in pertinent part, that “[o]n a finding by the court that an action under this section was brought in bad faith and for the purpose of harassment, the court may award to the defendant attorney’s fees reasonable in relation to the work expended and costs.” The District Court rejected Marx’s argument. The Tenth Circuit affirmed, in pertinent part, agreeing that costs are allowed under the Rule and concluding that nothing in the statute’s text, history, or purpose indicates that it was meant to displace the Rule.
Held: Section §1692k(a)(3) is not contrary to, and, thus, does not displace a district court’s discretion to award costs under, Rule 54(d)(1).Pp. 4–16.

(a) Rule 54(d)(1) gives courts discretion to award costs to prevailing parties, but this discretion can be displaced by a federal statute or FRCP that “provides otherwise,” i.e., is “contrary” to Rule 54(d)(1).Contrary to the argument of Marx and the United States, as amicus, language of the original 1937 version of the Rule does not suggest that any “express provision” for costs should displace Rule 54(d
....Congress did not intend §1692k(a)(3) to foreclose courts from awarding costs under the Rule.